The Best Diners in Suffolk County
Dinerpedia documents 65 diners in Suffolk County — spread across Bay Shore, East Islip, Farmingdale and more.
Among the most reviewed are Oconee Diner in Islip (3,873 reviews) and Peter Pan Diner in Bay Shore (2,531 reviews).
We also document 9 that have since closed, preserving their photos and stories.
Explore them all below, complete with photos, ratings, and community memories.
Open
Google
Airport Diner
Bohemia, NY
Long Island4.2(2,336)
Open
Google
Applebee's Grill + Bar
East Islip, NY
Long Island4.1(1,720)
Open
Google
Applebee's Grill + Bar
Farmingdale, NY
Long Island4.3(1,970)
Open
Google
Applebee's Grill + Bar
Riverhead, NY
Long Island4.1(1,752)
Open
Google
Applebee's Grill + Bar
Brentwood, NY
Long Island4.2(2,329)
Open
Google
Athens Diner
Middle Island, NY
Long Island4.6(312)
Open
Google
Atlantis Diner
West Islip, NY
Long Island4.2(1,358)
Open
Google
B L D's Restaurant
Lake Ronkonkoma, NY
Long Island4.5(942)
Open
OSM
Blue Point Diner
Blue Point, NY
Long Island4.4(398)
Open
Google
California Diner
Patchogue, NY
Long Island4.3(2,182)
Open
Google
Candlelight Diner
Commack, NY
Long Island4.3(1,173)
Open
Google
Coram Diner
Coram, NY
Long Island4.3(1,946)
Open
Google
Country Cottage Diner
Center Moriches, NY
Long Island4.6(420)
Open
OSM
Cutchogue Diner
Cutchogue, NY
Long Island4.6(454)
Open
Google
Diner Dash
Kings Park, NY
Long Island4.5(44)
Open
Google
Dix Hills Diner
Huntington, NY
Long Island4.4(1,833)
Open
Google
Eastport Luncheonette
Eastport, NY
Long Island4.5(347)
Open
Google
Friendly's
East Islip, NY
Long Island4.3(960)
Open
Google
Gabino's Diner
Farmingville, NY
Long Island4.5(511)
Open
Google
George's Luncheonette
Patchogue, NY
Long Island4.4(395)
Open
Google
Greek Island Diner
Wading River, NY
Long Island4.6(1,033)
Open
Google
Hauppauge Palace Diner
Hauppauge, NY
Long Island4.4(2,174)
Open
OSM
Heritage Diner
Mount Sinai, NY
Long Island4.3(1,358)
Open
OSM
Holbrook Diner
Holbrook, NY
Long Island4.5(1,547)