The Best Diners in Herkimer County
Dinerpedia documents 7 diners in Herkimer County — spread across Herkimer, Old Forge, Dolgeville and more.
Among the most reviewed are Crazy Otto's Empire Diner in Herkimer (1,901 reviews) and Applebee's Grill + Bar in Herkimer (1,318 reviews).
We also document 1 that has since closed, preserving their photos and stories.
Explore them all below, complete with photos, ratings, and community memories.
Open
Google
Applebee's Grill + Bar
Herkimer, NY
Mohawk Valley4.1(1,318)
Open
Google
Crazy Otto's Empire Diner
Herkimer, NY
Mohawk Valley4.6(1,901)
Open
Google
Front Door Diner
Old Forge, NY
Mohawk Valley4.4(898)
Open
Google
Home Town Diner
Mohawk, NY
Mohawk Valley4.7(22)
Open
OSM
Kylie's Diner
West Winfield, NY
Mohawk Valley4.8(190)
Open
Google
Walt's Diner
Old Forge, NY
Mohawk Valley4.5(1,294)
Closed
OSM
Southern Girl Diner
Dolgeville, NY
Mohawk Valley4.8(63)